DaysofPal – While Tel Aviv recently sought to secure its place in the global spotlight with a claimed world record for kidney donations, the celebration was shadowed by a much darker history. What President Isaac Herzog framed as a pinnacle of national altruism, a feat promoted to Guinness World Records to project moral superiority, was met with immediate skepticism from the very people living under the state’s military occupation.
For Palestinians in Gaza, the spectacle of “record-breaking” donations is not a cause for celebration but a source of profound alarm.
This disconnect highlights a chilling irony: as Israel markets itself as a global leader in organ donation, it simultaneously faces mounting allegations of harvesting tissue and organs from deceased Palestinians without consent. These concerns are not merely born of modern conflict; they are rooted in a documented legacy of state-sanctioned extraction, questionable statistical surges, and a persistent lack of international accountability that has allowed the bodies of the occupied to be treated as medical inventory.
Bodies Returned From Gaza Raise Questions
Among the most vocal critics was Dr. Munir al-Bursh, director general of Gaza’s Health Ministry, who argued that Israel’s celebrated “record numbers” could not be separated from longstanding allegations surrounding Palestinian bodies held by Israeli authorities.
Bursh pointed to what Palestinians describe as a deep contradiction: an occupying power that has stored Palestinian remains for years in refrigerators and anonymous burial sites known as the “cemeteries of numbers” while simultaneously presenting itself internationally as a model for organ donation and medical ethics.
He cited cases in which Palestinian families allegedly received bodies missing organs, particularly kidneys, without accompanying medical documentation, autopsy reports, or any transparent legal mechanism for accountability. Bursh called for an independent international investigation into whether Israel’s organ donation achievements had in part relied on organs taken from Palestinians.
Just days later, Israeli authorities returned the remains of approximately 54 Palestinians to Al-Shifa Hospital in Gaza City. Palestinian forensic teams attempting to identify the bodies reported visible signs of torture and what they described as evidence of surgical organ removal.
The allegations are not new. During the first weeks of Israel’s assault on Gaza following Operation Al-Aqsa Flood in October 2023, accusations of organ theft began surfacing from Palestinian medical personnel and families. By late November of that year, the Euro-Med Human Rights Monitor publicly called for an international inquiry after medical workers allegedly discovered missing cochleas, corneas, and internal organs including kidneys, livers, and hearts.
Israel and its defenders dismissed the accusations as antisemitic “blood libel,” arguing that the claims recycled historic anti-Jewish conspiracies. But Palestinians contend that such responses have effectively blocked serious international scrutiny of the evidence emerging from Gaza.
A Legacy of Extraction
The current allegations revive controversies that first surfaced during the First Intifada in the early 1990s, when Palestinian families and medical professionals accused Israeli institutions of harvesting organs from Palestinian bodies without consent.
At the time, then-Israeli health minister Ehud Olmert promoted public organ donation campaigns that similarly emphasized Israel’s humanitarian image.
The issue gained international attention in 1999 when American anthropologist Nancy Scheper-Hughes, co-founder of Organs Watch, began documenting allegations of illicit organ harvesting and global trafficking networks linked to Israeli intermediaries.
Her investigation later centered on the Abu Kabir Forensic Institute, Israel’s only facility authorized to conduct autopsies in cases of unnatural death. In interviews later made public, the institute’s former chief pathologist, Yehuda Hiss, admitted that organs and tissues had been removed from bodies without family consent.
Israeli authorities argued that the practice had not specifically targeted Palestinians and that organs had also been taken from Israeli soldiers. However, testimony aired in an Israeli Channel 2 documentary contradicted that narrative, with one pathologist reportedly stating, “We never took skin from the bodies of Israeli soldiers, but from the others.”
Despite the public scandal, Hiss never served prison time and was permitted to continue working at Abu Kabir. Critics argue that the absence of meaningful accountability allowed the controversy to fade without genuine institutional reckoning.
Israel and Global Organ Trafficking Networks
Scheper-Hughes later argued that Israel occupied a central role in global illicit kidney trafficking. Speaking in 2009, she described Israeli networks as having “tentacles reaching out worldwide,” alleging that transplant tourism involving Israeli citizens had been enabled for years through state-backed medical structures.
International investigations over the years appeared to reinforce concerns about Israeli involvement in organ trafficking operations abroad.
A 2001 BBC report described networks connecting impoverished Moldovan villages to Israeli transplant recipients. In the United States, Israeli citizen Levy Izhak Rosenbaum became the only person convicted under US federal law for organ trafficking. A New Jersey judge described him as a black-market profiteer “trading in human misery.”
In 2010, five Israeli citizens, including a retired military general, were accused of running an international trafficking ring that exploited vulnerable people in developing countries. Other cases later emerged in Turkiye, Cyprus, Kosovo, and elsewhere, often involving allegations that impoverished refugees or migrants were coerced or manipulated into selling organs.
Israeli authorities now classify such operations as criminal enterprises. Yet critics note that for years Israeli citizens seeking organs abroad operated within a system that faced little effective deterrence and, at times, indirect institutional support.
At the center of Israel’s recent world-record celebration is Matnat Chaim, an Israeli non-profit organization founded in 2009 shortly after Israel passed legislation banning organ trafficking.
The organization claims to have facilitated more than 2,000 kidney transplants. However, publicly available statistics have prompted skepticism among critics.
Between 2009 and 2021, Matnat Chaim reported approximately 1,000 transplants. In 2022, it announced 202 additional procedures, bringing the known public total at the time to roughly 1,277.
To exceed 2,000 transplants by early 2026, the organization would have needed to facilitate more than 700 additional donations within just over three years.
Data published by Israel’s National Transplant Center reported 923 live donor transplants nationwide between 2023 and 2025. Since Matnat Chaim previously accounted for approximately 63 percent of such procedures, maintaining the same rate would place its likely contribution during that period closer to 581 transplants, significantly below the figure required to surpass 2,000.
While those discrepancies do not constitute evidence of wrongdoing, they have intensified scrutiny from Palestinian officials already alarmed by allegations emerging from Gaza hospitals.
Additional skepticism stems from Israel’s historically low rates of registered organ donors. Only about 14 percent of Israelis have reportedly signed donor cards, a figure well below averages in many Western countries.
Palestinian Bodies as Instruments of Control
For decades, Palestinians have accused Israel of using bodies as tools of political pressure and domination.
Israel has acknowledged losing track of Palestinian remains buried in anonymous military cemeteries known as the “cemeteries of numbers,” where graves are marked only with numerical identifiers. Families often spend years seeking information about relatives whose bodies are withheld by Israeli authorities.
The policy has fueled enduring fears that some bodies were subjected to organ removal before burial or return.
Those suspicions resurfaced strongly during the war on Gaza. Palestinian doctors at Nasser Hospital in Khan Younis stated that recently returned bodies appeared to contain signs consistent with organ extraction, including cavities filled with cotton.
Calls for an International Investigation
Despite decades of allegations, documented admissions, and repeated trafficking scandals involving Israeli nationals, no independent international investigation has been launched into claims of organ harvesting connected to Gaza.
Critics argue that Western governments and institutions have consistently shielded Israel from accountability. They point to examples such as the exposure of the University of Southern California for selling human cadavers later used in Israeli military surgical training programs, a revelation condemned by the Council on American-Islamic Relations as deeply disturbing.
For Palestinians, the larger issue extends beyond the allegations themselves. They argue that the political environment surrounding Israel has made impartial scrutiny nearly impossible.
More than three decades after the first accusations surfaced during the First Intifada, Palestinians say the same pattern persists: allegations emerge, evidence is disputed or dismissed, internal Israeli investigations replace independent inquiries, and international institutions decline to intervene.
Shortlink for this post: https://daysofpalestine.ps/?p=74631
